FatButterCookies
Variety Pack (2 Dozen)
Variety Pack (2 Dozen)
Couldn't load pickup availability
Cookie Description
Can’t decide which cookie flavor to try? Our Variety Pack is the perfect solution! This delicious assortment includes all eight of our original cookie flavors, with three cookies of each, totaling 24 homemade cookies—giving you a taste of everything we offer. Whether you're a first-time Fat Butter Cookies customer or a longtime fan, this pack is ideal for sampling, gifting, or sharing at gatherings. Treat yourself or impress your guests with a wide range of irresistible flavors. Because when it comes to cookies, why choose just one?
Flavors Included: Chocolate Chip, Maple Oatmeal Raisin, Red Velvet, 'Sticky Icky' S'mores, 'Bam Bam' Sugar Cookie, Snickerdoodle with a Twist, 'Brownie' Double Chocolate Chip & White Chocolate Chip Macadamia.
Dough Facts
Net Weight: 810 grams (2 dozen); please note that these cookies are medium-sized. Eating 4 at a time is ideal but we've heard that our cookies are pretty addicting so we won't blame you if you have more :).
Ingredients
Flour, Chocolate Chip, White Chocolate Chip, Fruity Pebbles, Marshmallow, Chocolate Bars, Graham Crackers, Oats, Raisins, Cap'n Crunch, Macadamia Nuts, Butter, Eggs, Baking Powder, Brown Sugar, Granulated Sugar, Salt, Baking Soda and Cream of Tartar.
After stopping myself from eating the entire pack day one, and sharing with my entire family, we all can agree that these are it. The freshness after being shipped from FL to NYC is insane, I can’t imagine how amazing it would be fresh out the oven. The love put into these cookies shows from dough to packaging. It’s been quite the pleasure watching the progress of Sam and Kadeem expanding as a brand. I can’t wait for a store front “Mom and Pop” bakery to open. Will be household name soon.
Fat Butter Cookies blew me away. I tried every flavor and couldn’t find a single miss. The texture, flavor, and sweetness are perfectly balanced, something you don’t get with most cookie brands.
My personal favorite was the White Chocolate Macadamia, it was the first one I finished, and it delivered on every level: rich, buttery, and soft with just the right crunch. The S’mores cookie was chewy with a perfect marshmallow pull, and the Bam Bam brought nostalgic cereal vibes in the best way. Even classics like Chocolate Chip and Snickerdoodle felt elevated and thoughtfully made.
I’m a tough critic when it comes to baked goods, and these cookies honestly outperformed local favorites like Crumbl and Cookie Society.
Delicious cookies!!!
I ordered an assortment of cookies and I couldn't be more impressed! I received the cookies on Friday and shared them with my team on Monday as a sweet treat for my sweet team. Even after a few days, the cookies were still soft, moist, and incredibly fresh, which speaks volumes about their quality.
The assortment of flavors was fantastic—there was something for everyone! Each person who tried a cookie had nothing but great things to say, with comments about how delicious and perfectly baked they were.
The packaging was another standout feature: unique, eye-catching, and thoughtfully designed, it added an extra layer of excitement when presenting the cookies.
Fat Butter Cookies truly exceeded expectations in every way. If you're looking for a gift, a team treat, or just something to satisfy your sweet tooth, I can't recommend them enough!
Great cookies. Great customer service.
After stopping myself from eating the entire pack day one, and sharing with my entire family, we all can agree that these are it. The freshness after being shipped from FL to NYC is insane, I can’t imagine how amazing it would be fresh out the oven. The love put into these cookies shows from dough to packaging. It’s been quite the pleasure watching the progress of Sam and Kadeem expanding as a brand. I can’t wait for a store front “Mom and Pop” bakery to open. Will be household name soon.
Fat Butter Cookies blew me away. I tried every flavor and couldn’t find a single miss. The texture, flavor, and sweetness are perfectly balanced, something you don’t get with most cookie brands.
My personal favorite was the White Chocolate Macadamia, it was the first one I finished, and it delivered on every level: rich, buttery, and soft with just the right crunch. The S’mores cookie was chewy with a perfect marshmallow pull, and the Bam Bam brought nostalgic cereal vibes in the best way. Even classics like Chocolate Chip and Snickerdoodle felt elevated and thoughtfully made.
I’m a tough critic when it comes to baked goods, and these cookies honestly outperformed local favorites like Crumbl and Cookie Society.
Delicious cookies!!!
I ordered an assortment of cookies and I couldn't be more impressed! I received the cookies on Friday and shared them with my team on Monday as a sweet treat for my sweet team. Even after a few days, the cookies were still soft, moist, and incredibly fresh, which speaks volumes about their quality.
The assortment of flavors was fantastic—there was something for everyone! Each person who tried a cookie had nothing but great things to say, with comments about how delicious and perfectly baked they were.
The packaging was another standout feature: unique, eye-catching, and thoughtfully designed, it added an extra layer of excitement when presenting the cookies.
Fat Butter Cookies truly exceeded expectations in every way. If you're looking for a gift, a team treat, or just something to satisfy your sweet tooth, I can't recommend them enough!
Great cookies. Great customer service.