"Delicious cookies, whimsical branding, & love encapsulated. Fat Butter is more than just cookies, it's love molded into dough." - Kadeem & Samantha Fletcher
Try Our Variety Pack
New to Fat Butter and want a taste of all of our doughy deliciousness?! Then order a variety pack and get a feel for all of our best flavors. Your next go-around, you can order your favorites!
It includes Chocolate Chip, Maple Oatmeal Raisin, Red Velvet, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, 'Brownie' Double Chocolate Chip, 'Sticky Icky' S'mores, 'Bam Bam' Sugar Cookie, & Snickerdoodle with a Crunch.
The variety pack consists of 24 cookies and 8 different flavors. For each flavor, you'll receive 3 cookies.
It can also be the perfect gift for someone with a sweet tooth in your life.
Fat Butter's Finest
Homemade cookies that'll put a smile on your face.
-
Variety Pack (2 Dozen)
21 reviewsRegular price $50.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Chocolate Chip
20 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
'Sticky Icky' S'mores
14 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Maple Oatmeal Raisin
7 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Red Velvet
7 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
White Chocolate Macadamia
6 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Snickerdoodle with a Crunch
5 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
'Two Face' Red Velvet S'mores
7 reviewsRegular price From $16.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
'Bam Bam' Sugar Cookie
5 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
'Brownie' Double Chocolate Chip
2 reviewsRegular price From $13.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Cinnamon Crunch Cookie
No reviewsRegular price From $14.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per
From Dough to Delicious
At Fat Butter, we pride ourselves on baking these classic and modern cookies with sweet love, quality and teamwork.
Let customers speak for us
from 115 reviewsEfficient, personable, and professional! Kadeem provided excellent customer service. I recently ordered 2 dozen pack of cookies from Fat Butter for a corporate event, and it was a huge hit! Not a crumb left!! The variety pack offered a delicious array of flavors, from classic chocolate chip to unique creations like 'Sticky Icky' S'mores and 'Bam Bam' Sugar Cookie. Each cookie was perfectly baked and bursting with flavor, pleasing everyone's palate. The packaging was secure, and the cookies arrived promptly, ensuring convenience for our event. I highly recommend Fat Butter's dozen pack of cookies for any occasion, whether it's a corporate event or a simple indulgence in sweet treats!
Soooooo, let me tell yall about them darn Bam Bam Sugar Cookies!! They were perfect, soft, sweet, very fresh and was amazingly delicious!! Listen, my daughter Taylor approved this cookie and she is the most pickiest eater. When I tell yall those cookies didn’t disappoint and they didn’t make it an hour in our house. We love them!! Definitely ordering again!! My daughter wants Fat Butter Cookies to cater her birthday party and so do we!! So, please read these amazing testimonials we’re not lying, the haters are!! This little sucker barely made it!!
Great, delicious cookies with great flavors!
The owners are very nice and easy to deal with.
We’ll be back for more.
Had a rough week of work and had some personal issues arise. These cookies changed my mindset and gave me a bit of joy as crazy as that sounds. But these were soooo good and delivered so fast
Not only were the cookies the best I’ve ever had, but the owners were so kind and friendly and they delivery was so quick! I won’t be buying any more store bought cookies, they are my go to! Even the packaging shows care in passion in what they do, you won’t be disappointed! And everyone in the office loved them too! (;
Ordered the Variety pack and loved every single flavor!!! Most definitely will order again!!! Love yall!!!
This cookie gave me more snickerdoodle vibes. Fire! Def would recommend.
Gave this cookie a 7/10 because of preference. Im more of a thick cookie lover w more chocolate taste. But overall still good.
Literally... If you think you're buying this variety pack and are going to share, you're not 😂 Don't sweat if you gain a little weight, I promise it's so worth it. Every single flavor is so good, so soft, so moist. My partner loved the Snickerdoodle the most and my favorite was the 'Bam Bam' Sugar Cookie, who knew cereal and cookies go together like that? Real bad. Dipped in some milk... *chef's kiss*. I would absolutely send a box to a friend, 'cause like I said - you won't want to share yours!
Most unique flavor offered here & likely the very best - the base is perfectly crisp & there is a heavy crunch texture thanks to the cereal itself. This one is the best dipper - either in [Oat] Milk or in Coffee for breakfast.
Stuck in a three-way tie for my favorite flavor - the red velvet itself comes through delicious & heavy on first-taste, but the white chocolate chips are the unsung heroes of this cookie
Getting to the heart of the morsel of it all, love this flavour. I also gave a pack to my mom who felt the exact same way and she was even warming them up before pairing them with her afternoon tea. ❤️🍪
The variety pack is everything. From the red velvet to the snickerdoodle, everyone thoroughly enjoyed every bite and we will be returning customers soon enough. Can't say enough about the customer service and shipping. Can we talk about the presentation as well??? The branding and the packaging were done with precision like no other.
I recently ordered the variety pack, and I couldn't be happier with my experience! The cookies arrived promptly and were beautifully packaged. Not only did they look amazing, but they tasted absolutely delicious. Each bite was a delightful experience of flavor and freshness. I highly recommend Fatbutter Cookies for anyone looking for high-quality, delicious cookies. I will definitely be ordering again!
The oatmeal raisin cookies were perfectly chewy with just the right amount of sweetness, while the double chocolate chip cookies were rich and indulgent. The customer service was exceptional, and the cookies arrived fresh and beautifully packaged. I can't wait to order again and try more of their delicious flavors! Do yourself a favor and place an order with this fantastic small business—you won't be disappointed!