Always fresh , always delicious ! We ppreciate the consistency !
I ordered the 2 dozen variety pack as a gift to my brother for the holidays and my nieces and nephews absolutely LOVED them! I loved the option to add a personalized note to my order. The s’mores cookie was a fam favorite. Can’t wait to order again.
Family and friends love the cookies. The individual sealed packets make it very easy to take anywhere. We’ll be ordering more for the Christmas as gifts.
From the packaging , to the delivery process , seamless !
& cookies arrived as if they’ve just left the oven and cooled off. . Still soft but not mushy , savory and not too sweet ; just perfect . Sticky Icky S’mores was something different and I enjoyed every bit(e) of it . Shoutouts to Kadeem & his amazing wife Samantha ! Patiently waiting for a bakery. Try them out & fall in love !
Wow! These cookies were amazing! I finished more than I’m willing to admit in the first day 😂😂 I will definitely be ordering more asap!
The packaging is amazing ✨✨✨ Quality presentation doesn’t surprise me from them!
Great tasting cookies fast delivery they were gone in two days definitely will order again
Delicious!!! Expedient delivery & my family loved the taste & moistness!!! Will definitely order again!!!
Lets start with the cookies, taste and texture....amazing -- especially for cookies that got shipped in the mail. (Imagine fresh out the oven...ohhhh myy) Now the service, impeccable. Cookies got here very quickly and the FatButter team was very responsive and communicative.
I wasn’t too sure how the Dubai Chocolate would turn out in a cookie, but the experience is on par if not better than eating the chocolate itself. Well balanced flavor, rich overall without being overpowering and the texture is A1.
I like having the ability to build my own dozen, especially when new flavors come out. I love the classic chocolate chip and white macadamia nut then adding some of the new flavors is clutch! Love the new packaging since my last order and I’ll definitely will be back for more!
I knew I should have avoided these things. My fat 🍑 was supposed to be on a diet and I go giving these a try. Now...diet postponed🤦🏿♀️ these were supposed 2b for a family of 4. 3 for each of us and I done sat here @ 1am and ate all 3 of the vels and 2 of the chais. Why they had 2b so good...🤔 im gonna just go ahead and eat the other chai😋 I have such a better understanding of how addiction works. I'm ordering more, ion care. YOU READ AND DONT JUDGE😉
I bought the Dubai chocolate, sticky icky s'mores and double chocolate cookies for party favors for my boyfriend’s birthday. Everybody absolutely went crazy for these delicious cookies (especially the birthday boy!). In my experience with this wonderful couple - K & S exceed at every thing they put their minds too, and I was excited to tick off another box from their creative projects. BRB gonna go cry because I have no more sticky icky s’mores cookies left.
I bought the Dubai chocolate, sticky icky s'mores and double chocolate cookies for party favors for my boyfriend’s birthday. Everybody absolutely went crazy for these delicious cookies (especially the birthday boy!). In my experience with this wonderful couple - K & S exceed at every thing they put their minds too, and I was excited to tick off another box from their creative projects. BRB gonna go cry because I have no more sticky icky s’mores cookies left.
I bought the Dubai chocolate, sticky icky s'mores and double chocolate cookies for party favors for my boyfriend’s birthday. Everybody absolutely went crazy for these delicious cookies (especially the birthday boy!). In my experience with this wonderful couple - K & S exceed at every thing they put their minds too, and I was excited to tick off another box from their creative projects.
BRB gonna go cry because I have no more sticky icky s’mores cookies left.
After stopping myself from eating the entire pack day one, and sharing with my entire family, we all can agree that these are it. The freshness after being shipped from FL to NYC is insane, I can’t imagine how amazing it would be fresh out the oven. The love put into these cookies shows from dough to packaging. It’s been quite the pleasure watching the progress of Sam and Kadeem expanding as a brand. I can’t wait for a store front “Mom and Pop” bakery to open. Will be household name soon.
I’m not a sweets person, but the owners convinced me to try their Fat Butter Cookies. I ordered that very weekend, and bit into the most delicious cookie . That Sweet Potato Pecan Chai !!!!! Ouuu *breaks out into the its gooooodddd dance*, I would highly recommend & order again. Thank you!
Fat Butter Cookies blew me away. I tried every flavor and couldn’t find a single miss. The texture, flavor, and sweetness are perfectly balanced, something you don’t get with most cookie brands.
My personal favorite was the White Chocolate Macadamia, it was the first one I finished, and it delivered on every level: rich, buttery, and soft with just the right crunch. The S’mores cookie was chewy with a perfect marshmallow pull, and the Bam Bam brought nostalgic cereal vibes in the best way. Even classics like Chocolate Chip and Snickerdoodle felt elevated and thoughtfully made.
I’m a tough critic when it comes to baked goods, and these cookies honestly outperformed local favorites like Crumbl and Cookie Society.
So delicious and really feeling the new flavor but the red velvet will always be my favorite.
These cookies were absolutely amazing! I will definitely be ordering from here again. I'm certain these are the best cookies I've ever had. I can't wait to see what Fat Butter does next!
You ever eat something, and immediately have to do a dance because it tastes so good? That's this cookie! These cookeis are like a new take on your classic holiday flavors. That sweet potato and pecan mix is so good, and the chai flavors really bring this one to the next level! These can be (and will be in this household 😋) enjoyed year-round!
I didn’t need to chase this one down with any milk. The red velvet and chocolate with a marshmallow sandwiched in the middle was 🔥. This was like the yams and the macaroni touching each other on thanksgiving day.
The Dubai chocolate was absolutely everything. If ya missed, reach out, I’ll let you know how good it was. As soon I took it out the microwave for a quick 13 second tanning session, I had half of it already eaten.